Chapter 3: Functions of Several Variables
Section 3.2: Limits and Continuity
Show that for f=x sin1/y+y sin1/x the bivariate limit at the origin is zero, but both of the iterated limits limy→0limx→0f and limx→0limy→0f fail to exist.
Hint: Show f≤x+y≤2x2+y2.
To show that L is the bivariate limit at the origin, find δε so that x2+y2<δ⇒fx,y−L<ε.
Consider, then, the following annotated estimate for fx,y−0 = fx,y.
=x sin1/y+y sin1/x
≤x |sin(1/y)|+|y| |sin(1/x)|
Inequalities 4 and 5
Consequently, δ=ε/2, that is, x2+y2<ε/2⇒fx,y<ε.
Figure 3.2.21(a) compares 2x2+y2 with fx,y, the first in green, the second, in red. The green surface lies above the red surface, indicating that near the origin, 2x2+y2 is greater than fx,y.
Figure 3.2.21(a) f in red, 2x2+y2 in green
The iterated limit limy→0limx→0f does not exist: the inner limit fails to exist because of infinite oscillation in sin1/x. Likewise, the iterated limit limx→0limy→0f does not exist: the inner limit fails to exist because of infinite oscillation in sin1/y.
<< Previous Example Section 3.2
Next Example >>
© Maplesoft, a division of Waterloo Maple Inc., 2021. All rights reserved. This product is protected by copyright and distributed under licenses restricting its use, copying, distribution, and decompilation.
For more information on Maplesoft products and services, visit www.maplesoft.com
Download Help Document
What kind of issue would you like to report? (Optional)